Simon C Moore, Cardiff University

Is it better to spend £3 on a bacon sandwich or a pint of beer? Or to spend £2,000 on a holiday in the Seychelles rather than fix a leaky roof? As consumers we are usually very able to decide which option offers the better return on our investment – and often those returns will be improvements to our quality of life.

Valuing the what are known as the “affective consequences” – that is, the consequences which relate to our feelings and attitudes – of consumption decisions like this allows both individuals and policy makers to work out how best to spend limited resources to maximise quality of life.

Putting a price on something means we have a convenient way of comparing value across very different experiences and initiatives. When it comes to drinking alcohol, however, working out the cost of consumption is a little trickier than weighing the benefits one might get from a holiday or home improvement.

Drinkers would probably say alcohol makes them feel happier in the short term, but it can come with long-term consequences – depression, for example. There is increasing evidence suggesting that the more alcohol consumed the more miserable consumers are in the long term. Those who are dependent on alcohol or are heavy alcohol users are more likely to become depressed compared to moderate drinkers.

It is fairly straightforward to measure how much it costs taxpayers to treat people for alcohol-related illness and injury. In total, alcohol-related harm is estimated to cost NHS England alone about £3.5 billion every year.

So, we have a situation where we understand the cost to the health services of excess alcohol consumption, but we do not understand the affective costs of alcohol consumption. How do we place a value on something so nebulous as depression? This was the point of our newly published study and the idea is relatively simple. We know that those with a higher household income are happier. We also know that certain events make people unhappy. So we can ask how much we would need to increase someone’s household income to offset the misery they experience due to specific events.

shutterstock. Boule/Shutterstock

Cost of drinking

For our recently published paper we developed methods to quantify the affective consequences of alcohol consumption using UK Biobank data. We looked at 243,133 individuals between the ages of 40 and 70 who drank alcohol in varying amounts. We did not consider the short-lived euphoria associated with drinking, we were only interested in the long-term consequences.

If depression is greater in heavy alcohol users compared to moderate alcohol users, and depression decreases as household income increases, we can work out the increase in household income needed to offset the increase in depression due to an increase in alcohol. In other words, we can place a value on the depression associated with alcohol use.

We looked at average grams of alcohol consumed each day, and our measure of income was annual household income. On average we estimated that for each additional gram of alcohol consumed each day, annual household income would need to increase by about £210 to offset the increase in depression. This means that the increase in depression associated with drinking a bottle of wine each week could be eliminated by increasing annual household income by £2,400.

These results on the relationship between alcohol and depression also replicate similar studies showing that depression increases as alcohol use increases. However, the method we have developed is probably most useful to those interested in the costs and benefits of initiatives designed to reduce consumption, such as health researchers and those in the NHS.

Of course, our work has limitations. We did not, for example, test the causal relationship between alcohol and depression. It is quite possible that the association we found between alcohol and depression can be explained by other factors. I welcome criticism that helps us develop these methods and helps the scientific community develop to better capture the true costs of alcohol.The Conversation

Simon C Moore, Professor of Public Health Research, Co-Director of Crime and Security Research Institute and Director of Alcohol & Violence Research Group, Cardiff University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Order by: 
Per page:
 
  • There are no comments yet
13.02.2019 (13.02.2019)
96 Views
0 Subscribers
All Articles by The_Conversation_UK
0 votes
Visually expressing painful memories and feelings can help let things go. People with dementia can flourish and show creativity in ways they, their caregivers and loved ones never thought possible. Under the guidance of a trained therapist, creative arts therapies use painting, drama, dance and music to help improve quality of life for people with dementia. Around 50 million people worldwide have dementia and it’s on the rise. The condition affects the brain and can result in memory loss and inability to carry out everyday activities, recognise faces or remember words.…
09.05.2019 · From The_Conversation_Australia
Back in the year 2000, as a newly qualified sociologist fresh out of my PhD, I decided to interview my grandparents. Now aged 87 and 84, they had lived through most of the 20th century. I asked them to tell me about the most dramatic changes that they had either witnessed or experienced through their lifetime. Without a moment of hesitation, and without pausing to confer with one another over what might be included, they both answered me with one word: “food!” As working-class children growing up in the north of Eng…
30.04.2019 · From The_Conversation_UK
Some of the most famous scientific discoveries happened by accident. From Teflon and the microwave oven to penicillin, scientists trying to solve a problem sometimes find unexpected things. This is exactly how we created phosphorene nanoribbons – a material made from one of the universe’s basic building blocks, but that has the potential to revolutionise a wide range of technologies. We’d been trying to separate layers of phosphorus crystals into two-dimensional sheets. Instead, our technique created tiny, tagliat…
26.04.2019 · From The_Conversation_UK